SM are the initials of my college advisor. He was a jolly man, intellectually astute, but lazy in so many ways, a weed-smoking, pleasure seeking cheapskate who paid me the rate of my work-study job to babysit his adorable but spoiled children. I walked them home from school two days a week, and played with them for a few hours while he taught a class.
A bit of background, though. I was not a typical student in the Romance Language department, and was in fact, a transfer student when I met SM in my first semester at the prestigious university. Several years before this, I had graduated from high school and resigned myself to the state school that was a free ride for me, disappointed that my dad determined us unable to afford the school I wanted to go to, but desperate to get out of my parents’ house. Near the end of my freshman year, though, my dad was diagnosed with lung cancer, and a year later, he died. My frustration with the state school only intensified as I contemplated the brevity of life, so I quit, broke up with my boyfriend, and announced to my kind and reliable summer employer who offered to find work for me that I was going to be a translator.
I look back, and marvel more at my sheer determination than at the miracle that I did end up working in a translation agency in my mostly non-international midwestern city. Years of obsession with languages had paid off, and I ate up every morsel of experience I could, fell in love with a wild Latin-American poet, and finally decided to apply to the local university. I had come to know so many graduate students and staff from there, including the poet, that it no longer felt out of reach to me. When I was awarded work-study, I went to the Romance Language department and asked for a job. The department chair at first scoffed at me, but his assistant hired me on the spot.
I loved the people, but among undergraduates, I was a poor local student, while they were wealthy coastal transplants and kids from the much larger midwestern city a few hours away. I found my tribe, though, a group of music-obsessed literature students for the most part. I thrived. The office staff in my department loved me and channeled babysitting and tutoring jobs my way. I knew most professors’ children, and was usually paid well.
I am fairly certain that it would be harder now to fall so easily into the familial intimacy I found at SM’s house. I stayed for dinner and conversation with him and his wife sometimes late into the night, and never thought much of it other than that I was so inspired, by both of them. In this time, my relationship with the poet was not a detail I had shared with the department. He had graduated before I started, and was working in Texas. During my first year at the university, I flew down to meet him at a conference in Houston, and happened to run into my own university’s visiting writer. The writer greeted me warmly, and told everyone upon our return that he had seen me there.
SM had been a friend of the poet, and was undoubtedly intrigued by the gossip. I spent my last undergraduate year in France, and so of course was no longer working in the department. When I returned, though, I visited the university, had tea with the department chair, who asked me to come to graduate school there. In the midst of all this, SM invited me to catch up with him and his wife for coffee one evening, and I was happy to make a plan with them.
The fall of my return was a busy time for me. I had been working temp jobs to make up for lost income that I desperately needed. But I couldn’t find a real job, and when the last very viable possibility for employment fell through, I decided to take the offer of graduate school. As for SM, he had gained tenure while I was in France, and subsequently taught an uncharacteristically terrible graduate seminar. I had not yet heard all the rumors about this, so had agreed to sign up for his next seminar in rhetoric instead of the course with a very famous French writer who has since died. Ah well..
Shortly before I left for our coffee date, SM called me to change the meeting place to an infamous dive bar. Infamous to me, at least, because my parents had made jokes about it, with vague references to mob activity and unsolved murders. The neighborhood around the bar had been gentrified to some extent when we went, though, and either way, I had learned by then that the elite who inhabit ivory towers in midwestern cities are often fascinated by the plight of the working class, by the gritty neighborhoods that surround them. I circled the dark parking lot, and caught a glimpse of his late model Chevy. My car, also a late model Chevy, was almost famous, and he waved when he saw it. His car door opened, and he motioned to me.
I went to the car, and he was alone. His wife was in a meeting? Sick? With the kids? I can’t remember why she didn’t come, but she didn’t. I hesitated before getting in the car with him, but why? It was all so strange, SM just sitting out in the cold car. He started the engine to turn on the heat, and offered me a drag of the joint I only then noticed.
It was SM himself who first told me about the catastrophic failure of his graduate poetry seminar. He brooded about his situation, and lack of motivation now that those long seven years of proving himself were over. He reached for my hand, and held it for a moment before pushing it down between his legs.
I yanked back my hand. He did not seem particularly bothered, but I sat terrified to move, terrified to think. In any misgiving I might have had that he was sitting alone waiting for me outside, the worst I imagined was that he was drinking alone. He kept talking, mentioned my relationship with the poet, even brought up my near-rape in Paris. He asked if we could drive to see some Christmas lights, and I agreed, because I couldn’t remember how to open the car door, how to move.
Getting Started
My town had a resident with a well-known light show every winter. His yard became a wonderland of skating penguins and waving snowmen, and we sat outside to admire it for a few minutes before returning to the bar. Relieved to be back in a public space, I went inside with SM and had a beer, but I stayed for only a short time. And then, I had to see my former mentor every Tuesday for the first semester of graduate school.
If it had just been the odd night, I might have attributed SM’s behavior to a lapse in judgment, a misreading of my willingness to meet, something other than what it was. But in fact, he gave me a low grade in his class, while recommending me to submit the paper I wrote for it to a conference. He asked me to meet him in his library carrel, which I never did. He called me a few times, asking if I had made my submission, so he could send his. I realized that he had meant to accompany me to that conference, in Florida, in winter. My hope that he was trying to help me disappeared, and I avoided him. I did not submit the paper.
A year later, I was ready for my master’s exam. SM cornered me one day in the hall, and told me that he planned to be on my committee. In fact, he had already recommended himself to my new advisor. The year I had spent in graduate school, avoiding him, I had also become assistant to the editor of a big publication. I was happy. I had earned the praise of the graduate advisor, who asked me to stay for my doctorate. I studied for my exam, and I was ready, thrilled, excited.
The day of my exam, I looked at my three questions. One was a question that I could not answer. The topic was vaguely familiar, one of the many meandering conversations a few students had had during break for the class my mentor taught, not remotely related to literature, or the readings we did, or anything I could have possibly anticipated. I felt the blood rush to my face, and I began to sob. I cried for about twenty minutes before quickly writing a few pages to answer the other questions, which by then were also incomprehensible to me. I handed in my booklet and left, early, panicked and distressed. The department secretary called me to ask if I was all right, because the department chair had asked her if I was.
In my oral arguments for the exam, no one mentioned the unanswerable question, although I had spent the two weeks learning all I could about it. I was sure I had failed.
Finally, about a week later, the graduate advisor asked me to meet. He informed me that I had in fact passed my master’s exam, but also told me that he was intensely disappointed in me, and that I would no longer be eligible to stay for my doctorate. He said that I must not have taken the exams seriously, and did not have the qualities needed to continue in the doctoral program. I didn’t argue, and in fact, am not sure I even remembered how to argue at that point.
I never returned to the department, skipped the rest of my classes that semester, and mailed the final papers for my remaining classes. A few months after I left, one of my favorite professors, one whom I greatly admired, wrote to me. He had been out of the country during my exam and the deliberations about my fate. He said that I was somewhat vulnerable. And that no one can be vulnerable in my situation. I still have the letter. Others, students and teachers alike, told me they could never believe what happened to me. But I am not entirely sure that anyone knew the whole story. They just knew that my former mentor had betrayed me.
I wanted to report him. It was 1990, though, and it was a different world. It was an even more threatening situation in my mom’s view, and she urged me not to say anything. She said they would judge me, flirt that I was, my pretty smile and notorious boyfriend, my date to meet my married professor in a dive bar near the tracks. So naive. I floated then. I had a nice boyfriend who thought also that I should just drop it. I dropped it. I broke up with my nice boyfriend. I resented the mom who loved me. I left my hometown with a former fellow student in the program, one of the fiercest critics of the professor, the guy who would protect me. The guy who isolated me, who abused me, who said finally that he wanted to destroy me. I did eventually return to grad school with the intention of finishing my doctorate, but it never felt the same. I felt conflicted throughout my studies, still loving literature and writing, and working, but I saw demons everywhere, and tread carefully where I had once been bold, and finally let the dream trickle away as I created a new life in another direction. I raised children, and switched careers a few times. I have felt like a failure in so many ways, and remember sometimes the dreams I had.
I left the marriage. I should have written more. I tried to write more, but have always written around. I wrote about writing. I wrote about music. I translated and edited. I looked for love, and pushed love away. I fought for my children, but not for myself. I ran from passion and into the safety that was not safe. I buried myself in a busy life and in flesh and in comfort and in the mundane that I never wanted for myself. I eschewed the silence.
Now it is silent.
Now you might hear me, SM. You seem to have had a happy life, a happy family, promotions, sabbaticals, full career, all the things a person might want to have. I wonder if you ever thought of that night, or what you did to me, or what you made everyone think about me, or what you made me think about myself. I wonder if you ever did it to anyone else. I hope it was just me, but then, it should never have been me, either. Fuck you, SM.